top of page

Bakery
Local Orders
Events
Contact

Bakery
Local Orders
Events
Contact

Log In

Shay Butter Bakery

Browse by

All Products
Cookies
Mini Mix & Match
Seasonal Bakery
Shay's Mini Loafs

Filter by

Seasonal Bakery

Mini Mix & Match

Shay's Mini Loafs

$5

$8

12 pc

2 pc

24 pc

4 pc

4pc

6 pc

2 pc

4 pc

6 pc

All Products

Vanilla Iced Oatmeal Cookie
Price$5.00
Red Velvet
Price$8.00
Gingerbread Man
Price$8.00
Mini Mix & Match
Price$8.00
Best Seller

Soft Ginger Molasses
Price$8.00
Cinnamon Crumble
Price$8.00

Terms & Conditions

Shipping Policy

Accessibility Statement

Based in Wisconsin
shaybutterbakery@gmail.com

Subscribe to the Shay Butter newsletter for updates and special discounts!

Yes, subscribe me to your newsletter.

Email*

Butter

Find us at local markets:

Waukesha Winter Farmers Market at Pam's Kitchen 1st & 3rd Saturday of the month 9am-12:30pm thru March

Brewfinity in Pewaukee January 4th & every Sunday 11am-2pm thru March

© 2025 by Shay Butter Bakery

Bakery
Local Orders
Events
Contact

bottom of page