Mini Mix & Match

At Shay Butter Bakery, every loaf is baked fresh in our at-home bakery with care, intention, and the highest-quality ingredients we can source. We proudly partner with local Wisconsin farmers for core ingredients like flour, milk, and butter—supporting small family farms while bringing you richer flavor and a fresher, more wholesome product.

All of our mini loaves and baked goods are made in small batches to ensure the perfect texture, taste, and warmth you expect from a true homemade treat.

Allergen Notice:
Our products do contain nuts and are baked in a kitchen that handles tree nuts, peanuts, dairy, gluten, and eggs. We take great care in our process, but cross-contamination is always possible.

Due to the nature of baked goods and food safety regulations, all sales are final. We do not accept returns or exchanges.

If your order arrives damaged or incorrect, please contact us within 24 hours with photos so we can assist you.

All orders are baked fresh and shipped out as quickly as possible to ensure quality upon arrival. Packages are sent via USPS or UPS depending on your location and the most reliable delivery option available at the time.

Please ensure your shipping address is correct at checkout. Once the package leaves our kitchen, delivery timelines and delays are out of our control. Shay Butter Bakery is not responsible for carrier delays, missed deliveries, or items damaged due to heat or weather.

For any concerns regarding your shipment, feel free to reach out—we’re here to help make your experience smooth and sweet.