Question 1

Are your loaves baked fresh?

Accepted Answer

Yes! Every order is baked fresh in our home bakery just before pickup or shipping to ensure the highest quality and flavor.

Question 2

Do your products contain nuts or allergens?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Our bakery uses nuts, dairy, gluten, and eggs. Even if a product does not contain nuts, all items are made in a kitchen that handles nuts and cross-contamination is possible.

Question 3

How long do the loaves stay fresh?

Accepted Answer

Our loaves stay fresh for 3–4 days at room temperature when kept in an airtight container. Cookies can be frozen up to 3 months, simply take out and set them on the counter for 36 hours before consuming.

Question 4

Do you offer local pickup?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Local pickup options are available, please follow the prompts for local pick-up on our website.

Question 5

Do you make custom orders or large batches for events?

Accepted Answer

Yes! Whether it’s a party, corporate event, or holiday gathering, reach out to discuss bulk or custom orders.

Question 6

Do you ship?

Accepted Answer

We currently ship within the United States. All loaves are packaged securely to maintain freshness during transit.

Log In

CONTACT SHAY BUTTER

Contact Us

Wisconsin
shaybutterbakery@gmail.com

FB

IG

Subscribe to the Shay Butter newsletter for updates and special discounts!

CONTACT SHAY BUTTER

Contact Us

Wisconsin shaybutterbakery@gmail.com

FB

IG

Subscribe to the Shay Butter newsletter for updates and special discounts!

Wisconsin
shaybutterbakery@gmail.com